American Keystone Award

Long-Form Film

The Long-Form Film Keystone honors excellence in film and long-form visual storytelling through exceptional craft, depth, originality, and emotional impact. It recognizes work that explores consequential ideas and enduring themes such as character, courage, virtue, sacrifice, and the American experience.

Category Chair

Portrait of Christian Toto

Christian Toto

Founder, HollywoodInToto.com

Christian Toto is an award-winning journalist and film critic, and the founder of HollywoodInToto.com, “The Right Take on Entertainment.” He also contributes to the New York Post, The Daily Wire, The Blaze, HotAir.com, JustTheNews.com, American Greatness, and more. He is the author of Virtue Bombs: How Hollywood Got Woke and Lost Its Soul and hosts the weekly Hollywood in Toto Podcast.

2026 Nominees

Movie poster for Young Washington

Young Washington

Angel Studios, 2026

Before he was the founding father, George Washington was a young officer forged in the French and Indian War — and Young Washington tells that story with the reverence it deserves. Directed by Jon Erwin, the film opened to $19.4 million and has grossed over $36 million, proof that audiences still turn out in force for American history told with conviction instead of cynicism. Young Washington is nominated for The American Keystone Award in Long-Form Film for reminding audiences that the country’s founding wasn’t inevitable — it was built by young men willing to risk everything for it.

Watch on Angel →
Movie poster for David

David

Angel Studios, 2025

Before Hollywood tells this story, David was already the story — a shepherd boy who took down a giant not with size or spectacle, but with faith nobody else in the room had. Angel Studios’ animated musical retelling brings ten original songs and a cast led by Phil Wickham and Lauren Daigle to a narrative that has outlasted every empire that came after it: real strength isn’t conquest; it’s conviction. The film opened to a new box-office record for faith-based animation and rolled out to 43 international markets, proof that audiences are hungry for stories that take faith seriously instead of hedging on it. David is nominated for The American Keystone Award in Long-Form Film for putting scripture on the big screen without apology and finding an audience that has been waiting for exactly that.

Watch on Angel →
Movie poster for Reagan

Reagan

ShowBiz Direct, 2024 (re-release 2026)

Dennis Quaid brings to life a president most of Hollywood would rather not remember fondly: a man who called the Soviet Union an “evil empire” and then watched it fall. Critics were split, but audiences weren’t — a 98% audience score against a fraction of that from critics tells you who this film was actually made for. Reagan is nominated for The American Keystone Award in Long-Form Film for telling the story of American resolve, conviction, and the belief that principles can outlast an empire built against them.

Watch for free on Roku →
Movie poster for Nefarious

Nefarious

Soli Deo Gloria Releasing, 2023

A death-row psychiatric evaluation turns into a confrontation with evil itself in Nefarious, an independent horror-thriller that refuses to treat good and evil as a matter of perspective. Based on Steve Deace’s novel, the film takes real spiritual stakes seriously instead of softening them for a broader audience — a choice that turned it into a word-of-mouth hit built entirely outside the studio system. Nefarious is nominated for The American Keystone Award in Long-Form Film for proving that an independent film with real conviction can still find its audience without compromising on what it believes.

Watch for free on YouTube (with ads) →