The American Keystone Awards

Our Mission

The American Keystone Awards is an annual program dedicated to recognizing excellence, integrity, and cultural impact. We seek to honor works of talent that offer rich, deep, and true insights into the human condition while remaining grounded in the great American principles of moral courage, faith, family, and national heritage.

Each award category is guided by a nominating expert drawn from academia, the arts, and industry. These panelists ensure a rigorous and credible selection process, evaluating nominees based on merit, impact, and alignment with the program’s core values. From there, an independent council curates a select field of nominees across our four core categories. Finally, pro-American Coign cardholders pick the winners.

Founder

Portrait of Rob Collins, Founder of The American Keystone Awards and CEO of Coign

Rob Collins

Founder, The American Keystone Awards · CEO, Coign

Rob Collins is the Founder and CEO of Coign, a credit card company for conservatives founded in spring 2022. A veteran strategist, he was previously a founding partner at S-3 Public Affairs, where in 2017 the Trump Administration asked him to “quarterback” the successful bipartisan confirmation of Judge Neil Gorsuch to the U.S. Supreme Court. Before S-3, Collins was Executive Director of the National Republican Senatorial Committee (NRSC), a $125 million, 80-person organization. During his time there he helped reelect 12 incumbents and elect 12 new Republican senators, part of a historic 9-seat gain that was the GOP’s largest in more than 35 years. Earlier, he was a partner at the bipartisan firm Purple Strategies. Roll Call has named Collins one of its “Fab 50 Staffers in DC” four times, Washingtonian has twice included him on its “Power 100,” and Fortune named him the Republicans’ “Top Strategist” of 2016.

Award Committee Chairs

The American Keystone Awards are overseen by a distinguished panel of committee chairs who bring deep expertise across literature, film, journalism, and public thought to the selection process.

Portrait of Andrew Klavan

Andrew Klavan

International Bestselling Author & 2x Edgar Award Winner; Host, The Andrew Klavan Show

Andrew Klavan is the New York Times bestselling author of such crime novels as True Crime, filmed by Clint Eastwood; Don’t Say a Word, filmed starring Michael Douglas; and When Christmas Comes. He has been nominated for the Mystery Writers of America’s Edgar Award six times and has won twice. He wrote the screenplay for “A Shock to the System,” starring Michael Caine, and his political satire videos have been viewed by tens of millions of people. He currently hosts a popular podcast, The Andrew Klavan Show, at the Daily Wire. He is also the author of the memoir The Great Good Thing, about his religious journey; the USA Today bestseller The Truth and Beauty, about poetry and faith; and the Edgar-nominated New York Times bestseller The Kingdom of Cain: Finding God in the Literature of Darkness.

Portrait of Nathan Schlueter

Nathan Schlueter

Professor of Philosophy, Hillsdale College

Nathan Schlueter is Professor of Philosophy at Hillsdale College. He is the author of One Dream or Two? Justice in America and in the Thought of Martin Luther King, Jr.; the editor, with Mark Mitchell, of The Humane Vision of Wendell Berry; and the co-author, with Nikolai Wenzel, of Selfish Libertarians and Socialist Conservatives: The Foundations of the Libertarian-Conservative Debate. Nathan’s articles have appeared in First Things, Touchstone, Logos, Communio, Public Discourse, and Perspectives in Political Science. He is a recipient of Hillsdale College’s “Daugherty Award for Teaching Excellence” and teaches the popular online Hillsdale course “Introduction to Western Philosophy.” In 2025 he was awarded the Heritage Foundation’s “Freedom and Opportunity Academic Prize” for his contributions to conservative thought and ideas.